When a customer replies "please stop" to a promotional text, most people expect the messages to end there. Five lawsuits filed this year say that did not happen. The best known were brought against AT&T, and the allegations describe something many small businesses could do by accident: an automated reply that says "Sorry, we didn't understand that," followed by more marketing texts.
The cases are not about the National Do Not Call Registry itself. They focus on a separate duty that applies to every business that telemarkets, large or small: keeping an internal do not call list and honoring it. For a real estate agent, an insurance office, or a home services company that texts its customers, that duty is easy to overlook.
This article explains what the lawsuits allege, what the federal rule actually requires, and how a small team can set up a simple routine before the FCC's new opt-out rules take effect on November 25, 2026.
Small businesses can scrub a calling list against the national registry by uploading a CSV file on the MyFreeDNC home page, and common registry questions are answered in the MyFreeDNC FAQ.
What the AT&T Lawsuits Allege
As summarized by TCPA.com on November 13, 2026, two consumers filed separate proposed class actions against AT&T Services Inc. under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. One was filed on August 26, 2026 in the Eastern District of California, and the other on September 28, 2026 in the Southern District of Florida.
Each plaintiff says she replied to a promotional text asking it to stop, received an automated reply saying the response was not understood, and then received at least two more marketing texts. One complaint also alleges texts were sent before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. local time. The same roundup describes similar suits against State Farm and CVS, including one alleging that plain-language opt-outs were rejected because the customer did not use the keyword "STOP."
These are allegations, and nothing has been proven. The companies will have their chance to respond in court. The pattern is still useful for small businesses, because it shows exactly where an ordinary texting setup can go wrong.
The Internal List Is a Separate Rule
Scrubbing against the national registry removes numbers whose owners registered with the FTC. It does not remove customers who told a business directly that they want no more calls or texts. That second group belongs on the business's own do not call list, and the FCC treats it as its own requirement.
Under 47 CFR 64.1200(d), a business may not make telemarketing calls to residential subscribers unless it has procedures for keeping such a list. Section 64.1200(e) applies these rules to telemarketing calls and texts to wireless numbers as well. A customer who opted out directly can still be on a freshly scrubbed list, because the registry has no record of that request.
What the Federal Rule Requires
The minimum standards in 64.1200(d) are short, and most of them fit a small business without special software. The business needs a written do not call policy, available on demand. Anyone involved in telemarketing must be informed and trained on the list and how to use it.
When a residential subscriber asks not to be called, the request must be recorded and the number added to the list at the time the request is made. It must be honored within a reasonable time, not to exceed ten business days. Callers must also give their name, the name of the business, and a phone number or address where the business can be reached. A do not call request must be honored for five years from the time it is made.
The rule also places the responsibility on the business, not only on its vendors. If a texting platform or outside caller keeps the list, the business on whose behalf the messages are sent is still liable for failures to honor requests. Under the TCPA, private plaintiffs can seek $500 per violation, and up to $1,500 if a court finds the violation willful or knowing.
Why "Didn't Understand" Replies Are a Risk
Many inexpensive texting tools are set up to process one keyword, usually "STOP." Customers rarely write that way. They reply "please stop," "take me off your list," or "no more texts." An automated reply that treats those messages as unknown, and keeps the number on the marketing list, is the problem the lawsuits describe.
The FCC's new rules, published in the Federal Register on October 26, 2026, allow a caller to designate specific standardized words as the exclusive way to opt out by text, but only if that method is clearly disclosed. A business that does not designate an exclusive method must keep honoring opt-outs made in any reasonable manner. Our earlier article on the FCC opt-out rules starting November 25 covers those changes in more detail.
For a small business, the simpler path is often to treat any clear request to stop as a stop. It avoids arguments about wording, and it matches what customers expect.
A Simple Routine for Small Teams
A small business does not need a compliance department to meet these standards. It needs a short written policy and one list that everyone uses. A shared spreadsheet can work if it is kept current.
- Write a one-page do not call policy and keep it where staff can find it.
- Show everyone who calls or texts customers where the list is and how to add to it.
- Add every stop request the day it arrives, with the date, by phone, text, email, or in person.
- Test the texting tool by replying "please stop" from a staff phone and checking what happens.
- Remove internal list numbers and scrub against the national registry before each campaign.
MyFreeDNC handles the registry step. A CSV list can be uploaded from the MyFreeDNC home page for a free quote, at $0.0008 per data row with a $25 minimum per file. The site states that its national registry data comes directly from the FTC and that uploaded leads are deleted from its servers once the scrubbed list is downloaded. Internal do not call lists and state lists remain the caller's responsibility to apply.
A Practical Standard for Honoring "Stop"
The lawsuits against large companies are a reminder that the simplest step in telemarketing compliance is also the easiest to miss. A customer who says stop has given the business a clear instruction, and the rules expect it to be recorded and followed.
For small callers, a sound standard is straightforward. Keep one internal list, accept plain-language opt-outs, honor them quickly and for five years, and scrub every list against the national registry before calling or texting. That routine will not remove every risk, but it addresses the exact failures these cases describe.
This is general information, not legal advice. Requirements vary by type of call, state, and business, so confirm your obligations with a qualified attorney.
